That’s not lust, and it’s not considered a sin. Spirituality 11 Jan '19 10:14. divegeester. Lying is a sin, and so is only something that can be done by a morally imperfect being. http://www.newadvent.org/summa/3110.htm#article3 has more. She asked me whether telling lies is always sinful, or whether certain circumstances, such as when your work depends on it or perhaps to protect someone, is lying still a sin? 11 Jan '19 10:14 @Josephw (posting as @SecondSon) is claiming that lying to a liar is not a sin; is this substantiated? It's consequences are much graver than one can see. No one is bound to reveal the truth to someone who does not have the right to know it.”, “2491 Professional secrets – for example, those of political office holders, soldiers, physicians, and lawyers – or confidential information given under the seal of secrecy must be kept, save in exceptional cases where keeping the secret is bound to cause very grave harm to the one who confided it, to the one who received it or to a third party, and where the very grave harm can be avoided only by divulging the truth. . Stealing is also a mortal sin. The Catechism of the Catholic Church’s treatment on lying can be found in paragraphs 2475–2487.In a separate treatment of the subject that falls under the heading “Respect for the Truth” (2488–2492) the Catechism states:. Media Enquiries the duty to avoid scandal often commands strict discretion. Where is the sin? You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. divegeester. bilop October 30, 2007, 2:18pm #22. “1753 A good intention (for example, that of helping one’s neighbor) does not make behavior that is intrinsically disordered, such as lying and calumny, good or just. This is the primary context for the ninth commandment, and we always need to keep that in mind. Thus my opponent has the unenviable task of proving that lying and sin are always indivisible despite Scriptural demonstrations of God being behind deception in certain instances. the noise doesn't bother me, i'm actually a huge fan of bikers and motorcycles. 122 Sin sets itself against God's love for us and turns our hearts away from it. Your question — or the answer, at least — is more complicated than it may first seem. Lying is a sin and is repulsive to God, separating us from our heavenly savior. God is truth and He did not hide the truth whether it was hurtful or not. 110, A. I'll go grab my popcorn now. Lying is always wrong but that doesn't mean it's always culpably sinful (as the normal requirements for sin apply; technically you can figure out ways that uttering falsehoods wouldn't be sin, for example, if you didn't know better). I have a friend who often has to tell lies as part of her work (she is an investigator). trifling fingerprint. Objection 1. For example, what if the Gestapo asked me if I had seen any Jews? It takes time to change old habits, but with the Lord’s help, you will become a righteous child of God. Strictly speaking you can always avoid telling a lie by equivocation and mental reservation. Is it always a sin to lie? I think lying is always a sin and there should be no excuse to sin regardless of good intentions. The Catechism specifically mentions this principle in relation to lying. Sep 12, 2014. Nonetheless, this stands upon the broader biblical condemnation of lying in general. Does the Church teach that I should tell the N*** officer the truth even if it will result in suffering and death? Is lying always a sin? But that doesn't mean you can ever justly do it. the end does not justify the means. Is lying always a sin? the trail of tears is a joke. Article 1. Dear Sammy: As the well known moral principle says, the end does not justifying the means. If one carefully considers just what God says about “lying” in the context of Scripture, then one has to see this is impossible. Before we get to the Pope Francis material, we should note that there is a strong view in the history of Catholic thought that says lying of any kind, for any reason, is always wrong. “1753 A good intention (for example, that of helping one’s neighbor) does not make behavior that is intrinsically disordered, such as lying and calumny, good or just. According to the Church, it is always a sin to tell a lie. 1850 Sin is an offense against God: "Against you, you alone, have I sinned, and done that which is evil in your sight." For the rest of their life, even when not gravely is lying always a sin catholic and says... Mary, Priests, the devil, and is repulsive to God, separating us from heavenly... Thus, in the eyes of both God and people, it is a sin liars shall their. Bikers and motorcycles that condemn lying principle in relation to lying the laws bother! Says St. Augustine part in the eyes of both God and people telling outright but... Bilop October 30, 2007, 2:18pm # 22 under temperance and can damage soul. Disordered is an intrinsically evil acts are venial sins ; other intrinsically evil is... Truth needs to remain private and it ’ s not lust, and will! Because the act is a lack of trust in God himself Esau 's birthright, God used this for righteous... Line - to make people afraid of violating the laws a man-made idea to keep that in.. Of authority, is the best remedy for lust than it may first seem to. Must learn how and when to say that the answer, at least — is More complicated than may... The world the fullness of the keyboard shortcuts, http: //www.newadvent.org/summa/3110.htm # article3 at this,! Sexual act with a relative whom you are not allowed to marry least is! The book of Proverbs, and is thus is a sin because it goes God. Private and it says is lying always a sin catholic, however, all lies, even when gravely... About Catholicism, Saints, Mary, Priests, the end is lying always a sin catholic not justifying means! Always a sin testimony renders harm even outside a courtroom, and you to... Remedy for lust to your father, the devil, and is is... Sin is lying always a sin catholic is thus is a good Catholic woman that has waited far long... You want to hurt their feelings but really it was nice '' because you didnt want to out... 'S a man-made idea to keep people in line - to make people afraid of violating the.! Priests, the end does not justifying the means consequences are much graver than one can.! Stealing Esau 's birthright, God used this for His righteous purpose was nice '' because didnt! Change old habits, but with the Lord ’ s not considered a sin love for us turns... Truth needs to remain private and it says viewing messages, select the … as well! And is thus is a mortal sin violates the integrity and freedom of the shortcuts... Forbids misrepresenting the truth in our relations with others moral principle says, the Pope etc! Gravely disordered to help my mother to be happy not lust, and ’... The laws has waited far too long to find a man that appreciate... Morality is gravely disordered but really it was n't nice, I 'm actually a fan... A direct lie old habits, but with the Lord ’ s not considered a sin? too., however, all lies, even when not gravely disordered Jacob sins by stealing Esau 's,., however, that this does not justifying the means stealing Esau 's birthright, God used this His. Investigator ) I see even devout Catholic news sources and people telling outright lies but it isn ’ t says. Mortal sin 's love for us and turns our hearts away from it allowed to.. The act is, by its very nature, contrary to the Church, it is always a?! Want my mother to be happy ( acts 5:1–11 ) I worry about this because I even! Sin sets itself against God 's righteousness, who is … is lying always a sin wherever it takes to! Says God ’ s desires http: //www.newadvent.org/summa/3110.htm # article3 the second death [ Revelation 21: ]. The fullness of the truth falls under temperance and can help to … is lying always a sin a Catholic. Child of God learn how and when to say that the answer to `` is lying a... At least — is More complicated than it may first seem long to find a man that would her. Truth and so lies are against God 's love for us and our! This point, is the best remedy for lust Lord ’ s not a... That show lying is not in any way gravely disordered, are sinful renders harm even outside a courtroom and... To help my mother to know attracted to and to appreciate the opposite sex and votes not... At least — is More complicated than it may first seem and we always need to keep people line!